Palin on Gibson: C

I only saw the bit on the evening news. She wasn't impressive. She sounded like she was repeating talking points and uncomfortable discussing principles. She didn't sound like someone who had given much serious attention to foreign policy, or had serious considered alternatives to her stated positions. Her comments on Georgia and NATO sounded glib, her insistence the invasion of Georgia was "unprovoked" seemed ignorant of nuance.

I didn't see the curiousity or humility needed to recognize and tackle the learning curve ahead of her. She seemed a little overconfident, as if doubts about her preparation are nothing but the product of a hostile media. Friend, you are _as_ qualified as a two year Senator with years service in a state legislature. Neither of you are _actually_ qualified, and I personally would appreciate a greater recognition on your part of your own failings.

I though the Bush Doctrine question fair, and that she should know it -- and in any case, prepared to discuss the fundamentals of the policy of the past seven years. (The rhetorical damage was limited by Gibson's misunderstanding of the "Bush Doctrine", though I guess there is a school that says its about preventive war rather than holding sovereigns responsible for proxies.)

She did have a great answer to the "holy war" question, and her discussion of Lincoln's theology showed real depth. She can master what she studies, but she has to show that capacity on more contemporary and practical questions.

Now, I don't think Obama's foreign policy principles are much better thought out. He is far better prepared to speak about the subject, and his confidence suggests mastery -- but that doesn't mean the actual words make any sense. Then again, while I believe an Obama presidency would generate setbacks, at least these would then discredit a stated philosophy. (Or it might work!) Setbacks from incompetence don't even advance our understanding. If Palin can't hack it then we're choosing between a gamble on McCain's health and giving a flawed opposition policy a chance to show its worth.

Palin might get by with this sort of thing, but I was disappointed. She has to get to firmer ground or she'll do poorly when called upon to lead. More performances like this could suggest she can't grow into the job -- and that would bring McCain's judgment and integrity right back to the center of the debate.